You don't have a talent community. You have a list.

Most recruitment emails see <20% open rates. We're hitting 53%. Here's the playbook.

Hi everyone,

Most companies have thousands (maybe hundreds of thousands) of candidates sitting in their ATS and CRM right now.

Past applicants. Silver medalists. People who applied two years ago, got a "we'll keep your resume on file" email, and never heard from you again.

Everyone calls this a talent community. It isn't.

If it feels like everyone is starting a Substack, it's because they are

And it's not a trend. It's a signal.

People are finally internalizing something media figured out years ago: the most durable relationship with an audience is the one you own. Not the one rented from an algorithm. Not the one dependent on a platform's reach. The one built directly — where you have a first-party connection to your reader, your follower, your community, and no one can take it away from you.

Brands are already acting on this from a marketing lens. Shopify launched In Stock, an editorial newsletter for founders and operators. Rare Beauty built newsletter storytelling around identity and mental health, deepening community far beyond the transaction. NASCAR launched on Substack to connect fans directly to drivers and the culture of the sport, bypassing broadcast entirely.

These aren't vanity projects. They're infrastructure decisions. These companies understand that owned editorial compounds over time in a way that paid distribution never will.

This has not caught up to talent acquisition yet.

And I believe it will be the next big opportunity in hiring, especially as companies are rethinking their media spend on some of the biggest job boards in the space. When the platforms you've relied on start shifting their models, raising their prices, or simply delivering diminishing returns, the question becomes: what do you actually own?

The problem with job alerts

Most TA teams have tried to maintain candidate relationships through job alerts. It's not working.

The average recruitment emails see under 20% open rates. That means the vast majority of the people you fought to attract are not opening your content — let alone taking action from it.

A job alert is not a relationship. It's a notification.

What’s actually working

A real newsletter. Not a job alert dressed up in a template. An actual content-first email that gives candidates a reason to open it — and a reason to keep coming back.

I know this because we built one.

We launched Nurse Ascent because we kept running out of places to distribute nursing jobs. So we built our own community. Today it reaches 10,000+ nurses across all 50 states, and we collect 8+ first-party data points on each subscriber: where they work, what licenses they hold, what roles they're looking for, which state they're in, etc.

They give us that information because we give them content first. Community. A space where they feel seen.

Our open rate is 53%. That’s more than double the average job alert email.

That's what happens when you stop leading with "we're hiring" and start leading with something people actually want to read and be a part of.

AI has made this easier than ever

You don't need a full content team to start. You can pull from executive interviews already on your site. Industry news your team is already tracking. Thought leadership you've already published. New benefits, company milestones, relevant data from your sector. And yes, job listings, woven in with context rather than fired off in a blast.

A human still needs to sign off. But instead of someone's full-time job, it's 30 minutes of editorial oversight per newsletter.

And there's a compounding benefit most teams haven't thought about yet: that newsletter content is fresh, indexable material you can publish directly to your career site. AI models like ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity are pulling from exactly this kind of content when candidates ask "what's it like to work at [company]?" or "who's hiring in healthcare right now?" A consistent newsletter isn't just a retention tool for your talent pool: it's actively feeding your employer AI discoverability at the same time.

You already have what you need

The candidates in your ATS and CRM have already opted into your brand. They raised their hand. You just stopped showing up.

A newsletter fixes that. It turns a stale list into a living channel. It keeps your brand warm with people who are already primed to hear from you. And when a role opens that fits, you're not cold-calling; you're following up with someone who's been hearing from you every week.

You say you have a talent community. This is how you actually build one.

If you want to explore what this looks like in practice, reply to this email. We can pull your jobs directly from your ATS or XML feed, layer in blog posts, company news, and any external content that's brand-safe, and build the whole system for you.

It's not a custom project that takes months: it's infrastructure we've already built and that’s working, and we're standing it up for employers right now. I'd love to walk you through what that looks like for your organization.

More next week.

Best,
Summer Delaney
CollabWORK Founder and CEO

Further Reading

  • Something Big Is Happening — Matt Shumer's viral piece comparing AI's current moment with work to February 2020. He makes one point worth sitting with: relationships, trust built over years, and work requiring human presence are the last things AI displaces. That's where talent and employer brand teams live. The question is how long that window stays open.

  • Something Messy Is Happening — Ann Handley's thoughtful follow-up to the panic. Her point: AI adoption is still mediated by trust, regulation, human judgment, and accountability. Don't catastrophize. Do pay attention. A good read for anyone trying to frame this internally for leadership.

  • LinkedIn Abandons Traditional SEO After 60% Traffic Loss — LinkedIn formed an internal AI Search Taskforce after B2B traffic fell 60%. If the platform your employer brand lives on is overhauling its entire discovery model, that's a signal worth taking seriously.

  • The Year Of The Candidate Is Not About Kindness — Bill Boorman’s latest piece argues the candidate-friendly features exploding across platforms right now aren't about empathy — they're a battle for who owns candidate discovery before someone even becomes a job seeker. Relevant context for anyone thinking about where employer brand fits in that fight.